Journal of the Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka, (1996) 77, 54-65 WEAKENING EFFECT OF 2-FURALDEHYDE ON RIGIDOPORUS LIGNOSUS THE CAUSE OF WHITE ROOT DISEASE OF RUBBER K E Jayasuriya, J W Deacon 1 and T H P S Fernando (Accepted 10 September 1995) ABSTRACT Furfuraldehyde is recognized as a potential fumigant which has the ability to weaken Rigidoporus lignosus in artificially or naturally infected rubber root inocula. Addition of sulphur to soil at 100 g per 75 kg of soil, inactivated or prevented the formation of R. lignosus mycelial cords from artificially or naturally infected inocula. Drenching 2.4% aqueous solution of furfuraldehyde in to soil (1 liter/75 kg) where R. lignosus inocula were buried, caused weakening or inactivation of R. lignosus in artificially or naturally infected inocula. However, combination of two treatments had no synergistic effect on both types of R. lignosus inocula in soil. Key words: anatagonism, furfuraldehyde, mycelial cords, Rigidoporus lignosus, rubber INTRODUCTION White root disease caused by Rigidoporus lignosus (Kl.) Imaz. is the most destructive root disease in rubber plantations. Presently around 5-10% of the cultivated lands in Sri Lanka are affected and under bare patches due to white root disease (Jayasinghe et al., 1995). The pathogen spreads as mycelial strands on infected roots or directly as cords through soil. In Sri Lanka, the production of rubber is marginally economic (Pieris, 1966) so the focus of work in this investigation was to explore noval methods that might be as cheap as possible for control of the damaging white root disease. It was anticipated that such work might lead to exploitation of biocontrol agents either alone or in conjunction with soil chemical treatments to enhance the degree of control. 1 Institute of Cell & Molecular Biology, The University of Edinburgh, Daniel Rutherford Building, King's Buildings, Mayfield Road, Edinburgh EH9 3JH, UK. 54 K E Jayasuriya et al. Many attempts were made towards the control of R. lignosus, in which successful results were obtained using (a) some chemicals of the triazole group (Tran, 1985; Tan, 1990; Ng & Yap, 1990; Chan et al., 1991; Gohet et al., 1991; Lam & Chin, 1993), (b) 2% Pentachlorophenol in bituminous base (Jayasinghe etal, 1995) (c) biological control agents (Tong-Kwee & Keng,1990; Jayasuriya & Deacon, 1995) (d) fumigants such as furfuraldehyde (Jayasuriya & Deacon, 1996). In studies of Jayasuriya & Deacon (1996), furfuraldehyde completely stopped R. lignosus mycelial growth on Malt extract agar (MEA) supplemented with 0.3% furfuraldehyde. Furthermore, 3 hour exposure to 0.2 ml furfuraldehyde caused 80% inhibition of/?. lignosus mycelial cord growth rate from established inocula. When applied to soil for fumigation, /?. lignosus mycelial cord growth was suppressed and the activities of resident soil fungi were enhanced causing reduction of R. lignosus mycelial cord growth through soil. In most studies the results were obtained in vitro conditions. However, furfuraldehyde appeared to be a potential chemical for effective control of R. lignosus as it reduced the growth of R. lignosus on culture media as well as in soil (Jayasuriya & Deacon, 1996). Therefore, experiments reported in this paper were focused on drenching furfuraldehyde to soil and exposing R. lignosus inocula to furfuraldehyde or its vapor to investigate its fumigative effect on R. lignosus i n s u l a in soil. To achieve our targets three rubber growing sites in three agro-climatic regions were selected for the investigation: site 1- Rubber Research Institute premises experimental fields, site 2- Matara, site 3- Kegalle. The work reported in this paper was carried out both in Edinburgh, UK and Sri Lanka. MATERIALS AND METHODS Furfuraldehyde (Sigma Co. USA) was used as a 1% or 2.4% dilution to drench into soil. R. lignosus (isolate RT) isolated from infected roots collected from Ratnapura, a rubber growing area of the wet zone of Sri Lanka, was used throughout the study. The fungus was stored in 2 cm3 sterilized elm wood blocks. Preparation of R. lignosus inocula from rubber tree roots Freshly cut 15 mm thick rubber tree roots were washed thoroughly under running tap water. Soil particles adhering to the surface were removed. Then 8 cm lengths were cut, soaked in distilled water for 1 hour, and autoclaved for 45 minutes at 121 °C in 500 ml glass beakers covered with tin foil. R. lignosus was grown on 55 Weakening effect of furfuraldehyde MEA in 9 cm Petri dishes unti l the c o l o n y m a r g i n reached the edge. About 6 c m 2 b l o c k s of MEA c o l o n i z e d b y R. lignosus were cut f r o m the margins o f the plates and transferred asept ical ly to the autoclaved roots in the beakers. Then the foi l o n the beakers was sealed wi th m a s k i n g tape and they were incubated for 8 weeks. Effects of sulphur and furfuraldehyde applied to soil on R. lignosus inocula. Rubber root pieces (1-1.5 c m thick and 8 c m long) that were natural ly or ar t i f ic ia l ly infested wi th R. lignosus, were used as inocu la . Naturally infected inocula were cut f r o m large diseased trees o n the day o f the exper iment o r the prev ious d a y . An exper imental b l o c k in site 1 (site 1 - Rubber Research Institute premises exper imenta l f ie ld) was prepared 3 days before the establishment o f the exper iment . A 2 m w i d e strip o f land was cleared o f g round cover and leve l led . Ten bucket -shaped containers (made o f PVC) w h i c h ho ld 75 kg o f wet soi l (30% w/w) were sunk into the so i l up to g r o u n d level and f i l led with the same s o i l . The soi l in these containers represented "disturbed s o i l " . The containers had 2 holes dr i l l ed at the bot toms for dra inage. The so i l was a l lowed to settle for 4 days . Two types o f i n o c u l a were then bur ied in 5 r andomly selected containers about 15 c m b e l o w the sur face . Each container received 9 pieces o f inocu la w h i c h served as 9 repl icates. At other posi t ions in the experimental site, equivalent inocula were bur ied at 25 c m depth by d i g g i n g holes o f 15 c m diameter. These sites represented "undis turbed" s o i l . The f o l l o w i n g treatments were used: (1) natural inocu la in undisturbed soi l (NIUS), (2) art i f icial inocu la in undisturbed soi l (AIUS), (3) natural inocu la in d isturbed soi l (NIDS), (4) art i f icial inocu la in d isturbed soi l (AIDS), (5) natural inocu la in d isturbed soi l wi th added su lphur , 100 g/75 k g soi l (NIDS+S), (6) art i f icial inocu la inVl is turbed soi l wi th added su lphur , 100 g/75 kg soi l (AIDS+S), (7) natural inocu la in d isturbed soi l with added su lphur , 100 g/75 k g so i l and 1 l itre o f 1% fur fura ldehyde (NIDS + S + Fl), (8) art i f icial inocu la in d is turbed soi l wi th added su lphur , 100 g/75 kg soi l + 1 l itre o f 1 % fur fura ldehyde (AIDS + S+ Fl), (9) natural inocu la in d isturbed soi l wi th 1 l itre o f 1% fu r fura ldehyde (NIDS + F1), (10) art i f icial inocula in d isturbed soi l with 1 litre o f 1 % fur fura ldehyde (AIDS+ F1), (11) natural inocu la in d isturbed soi l with 1 litre o f 2.4% fu r fura ldehyde (NIDS+F2.4),"(12) art i f icial inocula in d isturbed soi l wi th 1 litre o f 2.4% fu r fura ldehyde (AIDS+F2.4). ' 56 K E Jayasuriya et al. In treatments where sulphur was used, it was sprinkled on the soil at 100 g/75 kg soil in each container, and thoroughly mixed with the soil before the inocula were added. In treatments where furfuraldehyde was used, it was drenched into soil as 1 litre of 1% or 2.4% aqueous solutions per container, after burial of inocula. Theoretically, these two concentrations may provide furfuraldehyde concentration in the soil water sblution of approximately 0.08% or 0.2% respectively (soil moisture content was 30%, w/w). After 5 weeks, root pieces were retrieved for examination and for isolation of fungi that had invaded the inocula. By visual observations, records were made on the presence of mycelial cords on the inocula, number of mycelial cords formed and their length, status of epiphytic mycelia on the inocula and degree of decay of the root pieces. Soon after root pieces were brought to the laboratory, and cleaned carefully without damaging the existing mycelia on them. Then, three lengths of mycelial cords (approximately 5 mm long) were cut from the surface of each inoculum, surface-sterilized with 70% ethanol in sterilized distilled water and transferred to MEA supplemented with streptomycin and chlortetracycline (30 iig ml"1 of each), to see if R. lignosus could grow from them. Using a cork borer, (9 mm in diameter) plugs were removed from bark and wood of each inoculum piece and transferred on to PDA supplemented with antibiotics at the above rate. Plates were then incubated for 2-3 days. Fungal colonies growing out were transferred onto fresh PDA for purification. Each fungus isolated was later opposed to R. lignosus on dual membered plates as described by Dennis & Webster'(1971) to assess its antagonistic properties. All fungi that suppressed R. lignosus were stored and maintained on PDA. Survival of weakened R. lignosus inocula in different soils in different agro-climatic zones of Sri Lanka Artificially and naturally infested root inocula were prepared as described earlier. Two experimental plots (1.5 m x 5 m) were selected at each of the sites, Kegalle (site 3) and Matara (site 2), on land where rubber had grown for a considerable period. White root disease incidence is negligible in site 2 compared to site 3. Holes', 20 cm deep and 15 cm diameter, were dug at a distance of 50 cm from each other within and between rows. Soil from each hole was bulked and pH was measured. Both types of inocula were fumigated in sealed glass desiccators by placing a cotton wool plug soaked with 0.2 ml furfuraldehyde on the base of the desiccator without touching the inocula. After two hours of exposure, the inocula were placed in the holes. Two pieces of inocula were placed in each hole on a randomized design. One inoculum piece was considered as one replicate and six replicates were employed for each treatment. Inocula were buried for 5 weeks about 57 Weakening effect of furfuraldehyde 20 cm below the ground surface. This level was selected for burial, as Pearce & Malajczuk (1990) indicated that significantly (P< 0.001) more rhizomorphs (mycelial cords) were produced by Armillaria luteobubalina at 12 cm depth than at 28 cm depth in soil. Then the holes were filled with same soil and the area was demarcated with wooden pegs. The experiment consisted of the following treatments: (1) Healthy freshly cut root piece.(control), (2) Naturally infested inoculum (NI), (3) Artificially infested inoculum (Al). (4) Naturally infested inoculum fumigated with 0.2 ml furfuraldehyde for 2 hours (NI-FUM), (5) Artificially infested inoculum fumigated with 0.2 ml furfuraldehyde for 2 hours (AI-FUM). After 5 weeks, the inocula were retrieved. Then the inocula were cleaned of adhered soil particles. Visual observations were made on the degree of decay, number of mycelial cords formed and their lengths, and the presence or absence of epiphytic mycelia of R. lignosus on the inocula. Inocula were then brought to the laboratory in sealed polyethylene bags. Then fungi were isolated from bark and wood as described earlier. All the cultures of potential antagonists were preserved and maintained on PDA. Isolation of fungi antagonistic against R. lignosus from buried inocula in soil The isolation of antagonistic fungi that could possibly colonize R. lignosus inocula was carried out as a part of the experiments. Isolation was carried out from all types of inocula buried under soil treated differently (i.e. soil acidified with sulphur, from inocula weakened and buried in different soils in different agro-climatic zones of Sri Lanka). Bark and woody plugs (0.5 cm in diameter) were punched from buried inocula and transferred onto PDA supplemented with antibiotics (streptomycin 30 jug ml"1 and chlortetracycline 30 /xg ml"1). The mycelia growing out from the plugs were transferred onto fresh PDA plates and opposed against R. lignosus on dual membered plates as described by Dennis & Webster (1971) to assess the antagonistic properties. RESULTS The separate and combined effects of addition of furfuraldehyde and sulphur to soil on R. lignosus inocula The experiment was designed to study the effects of furfuraldehyde drenched into soil and the addition of sulphur to soil, on the survival of R. lignosus in its food base. Sulphur was added to soil at 100 g per pot containing 75 kg of soil (30% water 58 K E Jayasuriya et al. capacity) and furfuraldehyde was drenched as 1% and 2.4% solutions to soil after burial of inocula. Inocula buried in the pots after soil treatment were excavated and examined after 5 weeks. . • ., In all the treatments where sulphur was used, no mycelial cords were formed from the inocula and the pre-existing cords on the inoculum surfaces seemed to be non-viable (Table 1). In all the treatments involving artificial inocula, the pre-existing mycelial cords on the inocula were weakened or inactivated during burial, whereas at least in some treatments involving naturally infested inocula the pre-existing cords on the inocula were able to produce viable mycelia on agar after burial. Apart from the sulphur treatment, the only other treatment that seemed to kill R. lignosus in the inocula (and prevent its growth into soil as mycelial cords) was the treatment (11) involving naturally infested inocula under soil drenched with 2.4% furfuraldehyde. Even though Trichoderma was not added as an experimental treatment, Trichoderma spp. most commonly were isolated from buried inocula. Effect of furfuraldehyde vapour on naturally and artificially infested R. lignosus inocula in soils of different sites of Sri Lanka The incidence of white root disease of Hevea brasiliensis is- comparatively higher in some regions of Sri Lanka, such as Kalutara, Ratnapura and Kegalle, than in others such as Galle and Matara. This variation may be due to soil or agro-climatic factors such as precipitation of particular regions or due to different levels of antagonist in the soil microflora. This experiment was designed to investigate the mycelial cord formation from weakened inocula buried in different soils in Sri Lanka. Inocula were exposed to 0.2 ml of furfuraldehyde for 2 hours in air-tight glass containers (12 pieces of inocula were exposed to 0.2 ml of furfuraldehyde). Then the inocula were examined and analyzed after 5 weeks. Subsequently, antagonistic fungi that had been invaded on to R. lignosus were also isolated and tested on dual culture plates as described by Dennis & Webster (1971) for their in vitro antagonism against R. lignosus. As shown in Table 2, new mycelial cords had formed from all types of inoculum in the two soils tested, but in the soils from site 3 (Kegalle) there were generally fewer new cords formed from fumigated inocula than in the soils from site 2 (Matara). However, as shown in Table 3, only Trichoderma spp. were isolated from the inocula buried in site 2 whereas different fungi including Aspergillus niger, Trichoderma sp. and unknown fungi were isolated from inocula buried in site 3.-Pre­ existing cords of inocula buried in site 2 were generally killed or weakened whereas those inocula buried in site 3 were viable. 59 Weakening effect of furfuraldehyde Table 1. Effect of sulphur and furfuraldehyde in soil on inocula o/R. lignosus Treatments* Degree of Status of Number decay of mycelial of inocula cords on the mycelial inocula** cords formed*** 1. NIUS fresh active 1-3 2. AIUS 50% weakened 1-3 3. NIDS 50% active 4-6 4. AIDS 50% weakened 1-3 5. NIDS + Sulphur fresh inactive none 6. AIDS + Sulphur 50% inactive none 7. NIDS + Sulphur+1% fresh inactive none Furfuraldehyde 8. AIDS + Sulphur+1% 50% inactive none Furfuraldehyde 9. NIDS + 1 % Furfuraldehyde fresh active 1-3 10. AIDS + 2.4% Furfuraldehyde fresh weakened 1-3 11. NIDS + 2.4% Furfuraldehyde 50% inactive none 12. AIDS + 2.4% Furfuraldehyde 50% inactive 1-3 * NI= natural (root) inoculum; AI= artificially colonized inoculum; DS= disturbed soil; S= sulphur addition; furfuraldehyde = drenched to soil; US= undisturbed soil; DS= disturbed soil,**active, inactive or weakened: when mycelial cord fragments were surface sterilized and transferred to MEA, active cords produced active mycelia on agar, weakened cords produced active mycelia from less than 50% of the fragments, inactive cords did not produced active mycelia at all, ****number of cords formed from the edges of inocula. 60 K E Jayasuriya et al. Inoculum type* Degree of Status of mycelial cords No. of mycelial decay** on. surfaces of cords formed from • inoculum*** each inoculum+ Site 2 - Matara control (fresh root) NI- unfumigated NI- fumigated Al- fumigated Al- fumigated 50% Al-unfumigated >75% 50% 50% Site 3 - Kegalle control (fresh root) fresh NI- unfumigated fresh Al- unfumigated 50% NI- fumigated 50% 50% Pre-existing cords not 1-3 viable Pre-existing cords not 2-4 viable Pre-existing cords not 2-3 viable Pre-existing cords not 2-3 viable Pre-existing cords 1-3 viable, new cords formed Pre-existing cords viable 4-6 Pre-existing cords 1-3 viable, new cords formed Pre-existing cords not viable 1-2 or none * NI= naturally infested rubber tree root inocula; AI= artificially infested rubber tree root inocula, **Degree of decay was observed visually by examining the status of bark and the wood, *** pre-existing cords were visually identified as they were discoloured and the newly formed once were clearly distinguishable as they were white coloured, + number of mycelial cords formed from edges of each inoculum was counted. 61 Table 2. Effect of fumigation of rubber tree root inocula of R. lignosus with furfuraldehyde before burial in soil in two agro-climatic regions of Sri Lanka. Weakening effect of furfuraldehyde DISCUSSION The results of the experiments have showed that furfuraldehyde has a lethal or sub-lethal effect on R. lignosus in soil. A concentration of 0.1% in media was adequate for 50% inhibition of R. lignosus (Jayasuriya & Deacon, 1996). Furthermore, R. lignosus on culture media was exposed to furfuraldehyde vapour, the lethal effect of this volatile chemical was confirmed: growth of R. lignosus was reduced 80% by 3 hour exposure to the chemical, at concentrations that would be achievable by drenching the chemical around the collar of an infested tree. However, the effect of furfuraldehyde in field conditions need further study. For example, it is not known whether the chemical could penetrate into the tissues of infected plants or into plant residues to weaken the pathogen and enhance its susceptibility to biocontrol [A similar study was carried out by Lim et al. (1990), using fungicides of the triazole group by adding them to soils and assessing their persistence in soil and their vapour phase effect on R. lignosus growth. Tridemorph was found to be the most persistent, maintaining a level of inhibition of 60-70% at 100 ug a.i. kg"1 soil and 77-90% at 200 /xg a.i. kg"1 soil]. Even partial weakening of surviving inoculum of R. lignosus by furfuraldehyde could be beneficial if the chemical also enables antagonistic fungi such as Trichoderma to grow and antagonize, the residual inoculum of R. lignosus. Such an alteration of the soil microflora by furfuraldehyde was reported by Canullo et al. (1992). Despite the substantial degree of control of mycelial cord growth by some soil treatments with Trichoderma, bran or furfuraldehyde (Jayasuriya & Deacon, 1996), the results of one comparison of sulphur with furfuraldehyde in soil (Table 1) showed clearly that sulphur treatment was highly effective in suppressing mycelial cord growth by R. lignosus, presumably due to its marked effect in lowering the soil pH. This experiment was done in field conditions and using in some treatments, natural inocula (infected root materials) of the pathogen. Because of the completely suppressive effect of sulphur alone, it was impossible to see if sulphur combined with a furfuraldehyde treatment would enhance the degree of control, but this possibility might be further explored, especially with larger pieces of host residue as inoculum units. In a separate experiment in which R. lignosus inocula were buried in different sites, it was noted that all the epiphytic mycelial cords were inactive after burial for 5 weeks in site 2 (Matara). It was also important to note that only Trichoderma spp. could be isolated from the bark surfaces of buried inocula. However, new mycelial strands were formed from buried inocula in both sites. 62 K E Jayasuriya et al. 63 From the results obtained herein, it may be difficult to predict that drenching 2.4% furfuraldehyde may totally kill the pathogen on buried inocula as it formed mycelial cords through soil. However, according to Table 1, it seems that the pathogen on the surface was weakened or killed. Therefore, it may be benifitial to supplement an antagonist to prevent forming mycelial cords. Apart from this, sulphur seemed to be highly effective on reducing and killing the mycelial cords. Results from the Table 2 showed that all pre-existing mycelial cords were killed on inocula buried in site 2 which can presumably be due to the fact that weakened mycelia were more sensitive for an attack by antagonistic organisms in soil microflora. This can be proved by the fact that, from all the inocula buried in site 2, only Trichoderma spp. such as T. harzianum and T. koningii were isolated whereas from inocula buried in site 3, different fungi were isolated. As Jayasuriya & Deacon (1996) reported in their results obtained in soil studies, proliferation of Trichoderma in soil may be suppressed by other competitive soil fungi. This was demonstrated well in treatments in which soil was fumigated with furfuraldehyde, where T. harzianum (strain TV 12b) sporulated abundantly. CONCLUSIONS The results obtained from the experiments reported here indicate that furfuraldehyde has a potential to control R. lignosus in vitro. Sulphur amendments to soil can cause detrimental effects on formation of R. lignosus mycelial cords presumably by altering the soil microflora in favour of acidophylic fungi such as Trichoderma spp. As there is no additive effect of furfuraldehyde and sulphur in soil, sulphur may be effective on reducing the mycelial cord growth by R. lignosus. It may be possible to suggest that furfuraldehyde can be used as a fumigant to weaken the R. lignosus pathogen and consequently amend an antagonistic organism such as Trichoderma sp. for a complete control.. REFERENCES Canullo, G H, Rodriguez Kabana, R and Kloepper, J W. (1992). Changes in soil microflora associated with control of Sclerotium rolfsii by furfuraldehyde. Biocontrol Science and Technology 2,159-169. Weakening effect of furfuraldehyde 64 Chan, W H, Wong, C P and Wong, C C (1991). Control of white root disease in immature rubber with three systematic fungicides. The Planter, Kuala Lumpur 67, 251-265. Dennis, C and Webster, J (1971). Antagonistic properties of species groups of Trichoderma. III. Hyphal interaction. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 57, 363-369. Gohet, E, Canh, T V, Louanchi, M and Despreaux, D (1991). New development in chemical control of white root disease of Hevea brasiliensis in Africa. Crop Protection 10, 234-238. Jayasinghe, C K, Jayasuriya, K E and Fernando, T H P S (1995). Pentachlorophenol - Effective and economical fungicide for the management of white root disease caused by Rigidoporus lignosus in Sri Lanka. Journal of the Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka 75, 61-70. Jayasuriya, K E and Deacon, J W (1995). In vitro interactions between Rigidoporus lignosus, the cause of white root disease of rubber and some potentially antagonistic fungi. Journal of the Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka 75, 36-54. Jayasuriya, K E and Deacon, J W (1996). A possible role for 2-furaldehyde in the biological control of white root disease of rubber. Journal of the Rubber Research Institute of Sri Lanka 77, 15-27. Lam, C H and Chin, S B (1993). Hexaconazole (Anvil 5Sc), a cost-effective • fungicide for controlling white root disease in immature rubber. The Planter, Kuala Lumpur 69, 465-474. Lim, T K, Hamm, R T and Mohamad, R B (1990). Persistency and volatile behaviour of selected chemicals in treated soil against three basidiomycetous root disease pathogens. Tropical Pest Management 36, 23-26. Ng, K J and Yap, T H (1990). The effect of triadimefon and triadimenol for controlling white root disease of rubber. Proceedings of 3rd International Conference on Plant Protection in the tropics, Malaysia 2, 31-35. K E Jayasuriya et al. 65 Pearce, M H and Malajczuk, N (1990). Factors affecting growth .of Armillaria luteobubalina rhizomorphs in soil. Mycological Research 9 4 , 38-48. Pieris, 0 S (1966). Economics of control of the white root disease (Fomes lignosus) of Hevea brasiliensis in Ceylon. Root Diseases of Tropical Plantation Crops. In: Root Diseases and Soil-Borne Pathogens, pp. 191-193 (Ed. T.A. Toussoum et al.) University of California. Tan, A M (1990). The present status of fungicide drenching on the control of white root disease of rubber. Proceedings of International Rubber Research & Development Board Symposium on root disease of Hevea 1990, China 47-54. Tong-Kwee, L and Keng, T B (1990). Antagonism in vitro of Trichoderma species against several basidiomycetous soil-borne pathogens and Sclerotium rolfsii. Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection 9 7 , 33-41. Tran Van Canh (1985). Use of Calixin and Sandofan F against white root disease and black strip of Hevea brasiliensis. Proceedings of International Rubber Conference, Kuala Lumpur 1985, 222-237. (Received 30 August 1995)